Analyst: Canada poised for biggest housing crash in history

A new book by financial adviser and author Hilliard MacBeth says that Canadian home prices are about to fall by nearly 50 per cent, leading to the biggest housing crash the country has ever seen – but its author says this could present an opportunity for well-financed investors.

"Investors who own properties with substantial equity can hang on without any trouble and they will see a new supply of renters who will be looking to rent after being burned as owners," MacBeth, a portfolio manager at Richardson GMP in Edmonton told CREW.

"That will make the rental market more balanced and it will be easier to find a positive cash-flow situation if rents increase. Of course, being well-financed will be the key to taking advantage of this change in the rental market."

The book, ‘When the Bubble Bursts’, which is to be published this month, says the reasons for this impending crash are years of ultra-low borrowing rates and home values bloated beyond the income levels needed to support them.

"Canada has a financing system through the CMHC where banks and other lenders can offer mortgages without taking much risk," Hilliard added.

"Household debt increased from $1 trillion to $1.8 trillion in 10 years between 2005 to 2015. About 3/4 of this total carries some form of government insurance or government guarantee. It’s important to understand that the insurance protects only the lend and the homeowner is still at risk for the total loss if the housing bubble bursts.

"An increase of that amount in such a short time is very rare, but when it has happened in other countries, it’s always been followed by a financial crisis, as the borrowing is used to buy illiquid assets such as real estate.

A number of analysts and economists have expressed concern that Canada is in a housing bubble, with the Bank of Montreal’s latest report, published in February, calling markets like Calgary, Edmonton and Ottawa “very weak” and hot markets like Toronto and Vancouver “balanced”.

MacBeth says the first market to correct will almost certainly be Calgary, which has an affordability multiple (ratio of house price to household income) of around 4.5 times, since incomes there are high compared to the rest of the country.

"But now incomes will drop, perhaps substantially, and therefore to get that ratio back to affordability might require a very large correction," added MacBeth. "Edmonton is similar to Calgary, although slightly less exaggerated."

In Toronto, MacBeth sees the condo market setting a dangerous precedent. "The surplus of condos in Toronto that is developing is dangerous too, as an oversupply of units could mean that condos, which are difficult to sell except when brand new, will be dumped on to the market by investors who have borrowed most of the money, or by lenders who have foreclosed on the properties," he said.

He advises that investors and homebuyers diversify away from the housing market instead. "Be careful to diversify outside of Canada and away from real estate as many listed equities in the financial and real estate sectors will be hit by the crisis in residential real estate."
 
 

Are you looking to invest in property? If you like, we can get one of our mortgage experts to tell you exactly how much you can afford to borrow, which is the best mortgage for you or how much they could save you right now if you have an existing mortgage. Click here to get help choosing the best mortgage rate

Investment Hot Spots:
Sainte-Croix, Les Méchins, Greely, Horton, Tribune

COMMENTS

  • by jamie johnston 2015-03-19 11:14:52 AM

    You can only write a book calling for a market crash - in anything! If you said there would be no change for the next two years, then that would not be a book worth buying. Remember 2004 and Garth Turner telling us there was a big crash coming in real estate. And he sold lots of books too. How long do we have to wait? 10 years? 25 years?

  • by Mitch Parker 2015-03-19 1:32:24 PM

    It's ironic that a publication which promotes Canadians investing in real estate would promote such a scare tactic book. Without have read it, I feel it's safe to assume it's most likely full of the same bs as all the other ones that have come before it. Investing (not speculating) in real estate has proven itself throughout history to be one of the greatest vehicles for creation of wealth. I'll take my chances utilizing proper due diligence, a long term investment strategy, and hard work over someone yelling from the bench that things are about to come off the rails. Your seat must be really warm by now...

  • by Freeman Yee 2015-03-19 1:42:52 PM

    If you ask a realtor where to invest money, they would say real estate, and not stocks because realtors get paid to sell real estate. If you ask a financial advisor the same question, they'll tell you to put your money into the stock market instead of real estate, because they get paid to sell stock-based investment products. Always understand how people get paid before you put any weight on their advice.

Get help choosing the best mortgage rate

Just fill in a few details, and we'll arrange for a Mortgage adviser to help you find the best mortgage for your needs

  • How soon do you want a mortgage?
  • Name
  • Where do you live?
  • Phone number
  • E-mail address

Poll

Would you vote for real estate board amalgamation