“Conceal estate” comes at a heavy cost—analyst

The hottest real estate markets in Canada—namely, Vancouver and Toronto—have seen unprecedented levels of activity the past few years, but a long-time market analyst stated that this development has mainly benefited upper-crust buyers and foreign investors.
 
“Their skylines have become stacks of safety deposit boxes for persons unknown,” Financial Post editor-at-large Diane Francis wrote in a February 26 piece.
 
“Letting rich people play fast and loose in Canada is nothing new. Billionaires can move offshore and never pay taxes again, like the Irving patriarch of New Brunswick did and countless others,” she added.
 
Francis, who noted that she has tried to put the national spotlight on the issue of illicit money in what she called “conceal estate” for years now, said that the noticeable growth observed in the Vancouver and Toronto is masking the actual situation—namely, that the middle class is bearing much of the heavy cost.
 
“The reality is that anyone who owns or rents property in these two cities pays a penalty — call it a Kleptocrat Tax. People are saddled with mortgages that are $200,000 or more higher than they would have been if the bubble hadn’t been allowed,” Francis said.
 
The article contrasted the Canadian situation with the U.S., where hard figures on the proportion of foreign real estate ownership (approximately half of luxury apartments in New York City) were publicized thanks to the efforts of a sleuthing press.
 
“By comparison, in Vancouver or in Toronto’s condo cluster the percentage of cash deals by anonymous offshore entities and/or “see throughs” or empty laundering vehicles, is unknown. And nobody’s gone to the trouble to ferret out this information,” Francis lamented.
 
The analyst is not optimistic of the government’s decisive action in the matter any time soon.
 
“Clearly, Canada’s legal, developer, banking and building lobbies are too powerful and making too much money off these activities,” she stated. “But letting them turn our real estate into ‘conceal estate’ must stop because it’s becoming a serious social, taxation, policing and economic burden.”

Are you looking to invest in property? If you like, we can get one of our mortgage experts to tell you exactly how much you can afford to borrow, which is the best mortgage for you or how much they could save you right now if you have an existing mortgage. Click here to get help choosing the best mortgage rate

Investment Hot Spots:
Ruddell, Yahk, Agassiz, Saint-Valérien, Caraquet

COMMENTS

  • by 2016-03-07 1:35:06 PM

    May be a "perfect" job for the Fintrac people rather then creating mountains of paper work created by Realtors
    for the little old lady who sold her home of 50 years, we must assure Fintrac (under penalty if we fail to) that she isn't a
    terrorist, drug dealer, or laundering money . Make them earn their wages on something useful. John M. BC

  • by Nick Slezinski 2016-03-07 3:10:09 PM

    I agree, the Perfect Place & Time for FINTRAC to start earning their bucks is now , in order to show everyone what they are all about ! They certainly could set the tone ti weed out some "snakes " . FINTRAC was set up for exactly for issues such as we see presented here ! Shadow purchases do zero to help the working people and only the "big bucks" buyers and sellers benefit in a major way ! ! I do not feel the extra paperwork required does much to protect anyone as far as 80 % of deals completed in past several years . I also feel that a huge tax on property flippers profits should be implemented . My personal opinions, of course !

  • by 2016-03-08 10:04:27 AM

    Fintrac's problem is that transactions through a law firm's trust account are exempt from Fintrac reporting.

Get help choosing the best mortgage rate

Just fill in a few details, and we'll arrange for a Mortgage adviser to help you find the best mortgage for your needs

  • How soon do you want a mortgage?
  • Name
  • Where do you live?
  • Phone number
  • E-mail address

Poll

Have your investment plans changed for 2017?