Fair Housing Plan triggered rent inflation

by Neil Sharma on 30 Oct 2018

In a keynote speech delivered at the National Mortgage Conference in Montreal this week, Benjamin Tal warned that instituting rent control could spell disaster.

Speaking specifically about Ontario’s Fair Housing Plan, introduced in April 2017, Tal says it triggered rent control inflation.

“To understand the condo market, we must understand the rental market,” said Tal, the deputy chief economist of CIBC World Markets. “The government of Ontario with the Fair Housing Plan decided to introduce rent control. I think it’s a bad idea because we need to develop a rental mentality; we don’t need to maximize homeownership. Renting should be okay.”

According to a report released last year by the Canadian Centre for Economic Analysis, 70% of Ontarians are living in homes with either too much or too little space, and that has had a deleterious impact on the shelter consumption affordability ratio. Perhaps it is not surprising, then, that Tal is advocating for fewer homeowners, however, the implementation of rent control may stymie any progress on that front.

“We should reach a situation in which you are 35 years old with two kids, and if you’re renting nothing is wrong with you. We need to see more purpose-built rentals, just to provide more manoeuvering. The government introduced rent control, which I think is a very bad idea.

“There’s a Swedish economist who said ‘Rent control is the best way to destroy a city, maybe besides bombing it.’”

Roughly 50% of condominium units in Toronto and Vancouver are investor-owned, which leads Tal to wonder what will happen when they stop investing. An Urbanation report earlier this year revealed that 44% of Toronto condo investors have negative cash flow, and Tal added that many are losing upwards of $1,000 a month.

However, not everybody believes they’re losing on their condo investment in Canada’s largest city, because their tenants are paying mortgages on units their children will one day live in.

“Toronto’s and Vancouver’s biggest issue is land supply, and the supply of housing is getting worse,” said Tal. “In the short-term, the market will go down. Long-term, [prices] will go up.”

Post a Comment

Most Trending News

Fixed-rate mortgages have gone up, but it doesn’t matter

News of a fixed rate increase might inspire consumers driven by fear of being priced out of the market in Canada.

Read More
Post-COVID return to the office depends on where you live

Even before COVID-19 moved us all to work from home, reevaluations of office space were already underway, but not nearly to the extent they are now.

Read More
Millions in delayed closing compensation left unclaimed

This consultant and real estate investor said that a third of new construction properties built every year in Ontario have legitimate claims for reimbursement, but they aren't taken advantage of.

Read More